Subscribe by Email

Your email:

Call for Blog Articles

Want to share your experiences, advice, or ideas with the GrammarPhile community? Do you have grammar, punctuation, editing questions you'd like answered? Submit guest post ideas or questions to conni@proofreadnow.com.

Alltop. We're kind of a big deal.

Posts by category

The GrammarPhile Blog

Current Articles | RSS Feed RSS Feed

Idioms and Word Derivations

  
  
  

Every time I write the vocabulary list for our weekly (well, we try) GrammarTip, I try to come up with a theme, based on the calendar or what's happening that week. Mother's Day, the World Series, elections - we've touched on many themes. Recently, my pizza-restaurant calendar informed me it was National Pizza Month, so we went with a pizza theme. Somewhere in the mix we encouraged readers to go out and get a great shrimp scampi pizza.

Well, well. A reader at a marketing firm, who works in a glass office (I know. He gave his web address; we went by and looked.) threw a stone. "That's redundant. In Italian," he wrote, "scampi means a shrimp-related animal, something like a lobster. So saying ‘shrimp scampi' is like saying ‘lobster lobster.'" Huh?

That's not true. It's not like saying "panini sandwich" or "Mount Fujiyama." Those are redundancies. Everybody knows that. Right? But here in America, ‘scampi' is more an idiom for a way of cooking something...with garlic, butter, and often a dry white wine. After all, go to many authentically Italian restaurants in America and you'll find chicken scampi, fish scampi, and, of course, shrimp scampi on the menu. And in Italian, the word for shrimp isn't even scampi. It's gamberi.

It got me wondering: What other foods are there where idiom has replaced the derivation of the word? Can you think of any? Blog back. We'll make a list.

Comments

So what's the story with "panini sandwich"? Why is that redundant?
Posted @ Wednesday, October 14, 2009 1:13 PM by Kathleen
I believe "panini sandwich" is redundant because a panini is a sandwich, by definition. Just like "hoagie sandwich." 
 
 
 
I've been trying to think of more examples of this, but I'm stumped!
Posted @ Sunday, October 18, 2009 11:04 AM by Asia
How about Chicken Fried Chicken? It sounds like a headline for a story about avian fratricide. 
 
Posted @ Monday, October 19, 2009 8:04 AM by Rick
"Chicken fried chicken" is an outstanding entry! I've had it, and I've had chicken fried steak. Both are great! See y'all in Texshus sometime! 
 
Posted @ Tuesday, October 20, 2009 1:57 PM by Phil Jamieson
Post Comment
Name
 *
Email
 *
Website (optional)
Comment
 *

Allowed tags: <a> link, <b> bold, <i> italics